Swap Fees for EA Traders: Overnight Costs, the Triple Swap Day and Swap-Free Accounts

person
FXVPS
Share
Swap Fees for EA Traders: Overnight Costs, the Triple Swap Day and Swap-Free Accounts

Your EA had a quiet week. It held a handful of positions for a few days, closed them near break-even, and yet the account is down. You open the History tab, add the Swap column, and there it is: a small negative number on every trade that stayed open overnight, and one much bigger number on Wednesday.

Swap is the cost (or credit) of holding a position past the daily rollover. For a scalper that closes everything within minutes, it barely matters. For a swing EA, a grid or a basket strategy that can hold positions for days, it can be the difference between a strategy that works and one that slowly bleeds.

This post explains what swap is, how MetaTrader shows it, why one day a week usually costs three times as much, and how to check whether swap is quietly eating your EA’s results.

What Swap Actually Is

When you hold a forex or CFD position past the broker’s daily rollover, the broker rolls it to the next value date and applies a financing adjustment. That adjustment is the swap.

  • Negative swap is a charge taken from your account.
  • Positive swap is a credit paid into it.
  • Long and short swap differ. The same symbol usually has one value for buys and another for sells, and they are often both negative once the broker’s markup is included.

Swap is applied only to positions that are open at rollover. Close before rollover and that day’s swap does not apply. Open after rollover and you have until the next one.

For more on what else happens around that time of day, see daily rollover and spread widening for EAs.

Where to Find Swap in MetaTrader

Every swap figure you need is in the terminal itself.

  1. Open the symbol’s specification. In Market Watch, right-click the symbol and choose Specification.
  2. Read Swap Long and Swap Short. These are the values for buy and sell positions.
  3. Check the swap type or calculation. This tells you the unit the values are in: points, money in the account currency, or a percentage, depending on the broker’s setup.
  4. Find the triple swap day. In MT5 this field is labelled “3-days swap”. It names the weekday on which three days of swap are charged.

For a full walkthrough of every field in that window, see the Symbol Specification window explained.

Four steps to find swap values and the triple swap day in MetaTrader

💡 Tip: Swap values change. Brokers update them as interest rates and their own pricing move, so check the specification again every few months rather than relying on a number you noted last year.

Why One Day Costs Three Times as Much

Spot forex settles two business days after the trade. A position rolled over on Wednesday night settles across the weekend, so the broker applies three days of financing in one go to cover Saturday and Sunday.

That is why many brokers show Wednesday as the triple swap day for forex. It is not universal: the same broker can use a different day for other instruments. Some list Friday for crypto CFDs, for example. Never assume. Read the “3-days swap” field for each symbol your EA trades.

📊 Key Stat: On the triple swap day, a position held over rollover pays three days of swap at once. One night’s hold costs as much as three ordinary nights.

What This Means for an EA

  • Grids and baskets can carry many open positions at rollover, so a triple swap multiplies across all of them.
  • Swing EAs that enter on Tuesday or Wednesday and hold for a few days will almost always cross a triple swap.
  • Strategies that look fine in a short demo may never have crossed a triple swap day at all.

⚠️ Warning: A strategy with a small average profit per trade and long holding times can be turned into a losing one by swap alone. Check the swap column before deciding a strategy has an edge.

Swap in the Strategy Tester

The MT4 and MT5 Strategy Testers apply swap using the symbol’s current settings. That is useful, but it has limits:

  • It uses today’s swap values for the whole test. Historical swap rates were different, sometimes positive where today they are negative.
  • Swap is easy to miss in the report. Look at the trade list and the swap figures, not only the net profit line.
  • A test that closes trades before rollover will show no swap at all, which may not match how the EA behaves live if timing shifts.

If you are comparing a backtest with live results, swap is one of the usual suspects. See why your backtest does not match live results.

How to Check What Swap Is Costing You

The quickest check uses the account history in the terminal:

  1. Open the Terminal (Toolbox in MT5) and go to the History tab.
  2. Right-click and make sure the Swap column is shown.
  3. Set the period to the last month or longer.
  4. Compare total swap with total profit. If swap is a large share of your gross profit, it deserves attention.

If you track the account on Myfxbook or FX Blue, both separate swap from trading profit in their statistics. See Myfxbook and FX Blue account tracking on a VPS.

Checklist for reviewing what swap is costing an EA

Ways to Reduce Swap Costs

There is no trick that makes swap disappear, but there are honest choices:

  • Close before rollover if your strategy allows it. Many intraday EAs have a “close all at” time input. Make sure it is set in broker server time, not your local time. See broker server time vs your VPS clock.
  • Avoid opening new positions just before the triple swap day if your strategy does not depend on them.
  • Compare brokers. Swap rates differ from broker to broker for the same symbol. Two brokers can quote similar spreads and very different swaps.
  • Ask about swap-free accounts. Many brokers offer them, often for religious reasons. They usually replace swap with another fee or have conditions on how long positions may be held. Read the broker’s terms before switching an EA to one.
  • Consider the account type. Raw and standard accounts differ in spread and commission, and sometimes in swap. See raw vs standard accounts for EA trading costs.

✅ Best Practice: Before running any EA that holds positions overnight, write down the swap long, swap short and triple swap day for every symbol it trades. Recheck them every quarter and whenever you change broker.

Does a VPS Change Swap?

No. Swap is set by your broker and applied on their server. Your VPS location, latency and plan have no effect on it.

What a VPS does is keep the EA running so that its own swap-avoidance logic works. A “close all before rollover” rule only fires if the terminal is open and connected at that moment. If your home PC is asleep, the EA cannot close anything, and every position it meant to close pays swap. See what stops working when your MT4 terminal goes offline.

Swap-sensitive strategies are usually swing EAs, grids and baskets. Size by how many terminals you run:

  • Core ($29/mo, 2GB RAM, 1 vCPU): one or two terminals running a few EAs.
  • Pro ($39/mo, 4GB RAM, 2 vCPU): several terminals, or grids with many open positions.
  • Scaling ($79/mo, 8GB RAM, 4 vCPU): many terminals, prop firm accounts and copiers.

See the pricing page, or try it on the $2.99 7-day trial.

Why FXVPS for EA Traders

  • Your terminal stays connected at rollover, so time-based close rules actually run.
  • Locations near your broker’s servers in London, New York, Tokyo, Hong Kong and more than 15 others.
  • Dedicated resources for terminals that run around the clock.
  • Full Windows desktop so you can check specifications, history and logs any time over Remote Desktop.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is swap in forex?

It is the financing charge or credit applied to a position held past the broker’s daily rollover. It can be negative or positive and usually differs for buys and sells.

Why is swap tripled on Wednesday?

Spot forex settles two business days after the trade, so positions rolled on Wednesday settle over the weekend. Many brokers charge three days of swap that night. Check the “3-days swap” field for each symbol, because some instruments use another day.

Where can I see the swap I have paid?

In the History tab of the Terminal or Toolbox window. Right-click and enable the Swap column if it is hidden.

Does the Strategy Tester include swap?

Yes, using the symbol’s current swap settings. Historical swap rates were different, so long backtests are only an approximation.

Does my VPS affect swap?

No. Swap is set and applied by your broker. A VPS only makes sure your EA is running to close positions when its rules say so.